The Better Mouse Trap Co. / sample paperwork

Basic — Design for manufacture and assembly

BasicRevision C12026-10-24Planning draft18 entries
Basic — Design for manufacture and assemblyBMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-DFM-001 · Rev C1
Company
The Better Mouse Trap Co.
Project / product line
Basic trap
Document
Basic — Design for manufacture and assembly
Document no.
BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-DFM-001
Revision
C1
Status
Planning draft
Start date
2026-10-24
Revision date
2026-10-24
Prepared by / owner
Sam Reed, mechanical, BASIC-C1
Checklist ID
BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-DFM-001 Rev C1
Scope
BASIC-C1 shell, door, and latch, parts BASIC-01 through BASIC-06.
Reviewer
Casey Holt
Review date
Planned 2026-11-01. Pending as of 2026-10-28. The review has not been held.
Team
Alex Meadow, packet owner; Sam Reed, mechanical lead; Robin Keel, animal-welfare reviewer; Ira Bell, Bell Sample Lab (test lab)
Approved by
review pending. Alex Meadow, Planning draft C1, unsigned.
Basic — Design for Manufacture and Assembly
Item / review questionAnswer / findingResult / statusEvidenceResponsibility / action

Item ID: DFM-01

Question: What performance and safety requirements drive the design?

Answer / assumption: R01–R06 and CTQ01–CTQ14 set the geometry a tool must not drop: latch hold after 100 dry cycles and a 5 N outward pull (DF01, RPN 210, CP01), raised opposing vents (DF02, RPN 252, CP02), release slider kept 30 mm off the door path (DF03, RPN 192, CP03), tool-free wash of rounded corners (DF04, RPN 240, CP04), captive bait pocket with no loose insert (DF05, RPN 162, CP05), and a clear occupancy window (DF06, RPN 432, CP06). Basic has no radio, battery, or propeller.

Explanation: CTQ01–CTQ14 are the features the mold and the assembly have to be able to make. CTQ01–CTQ06 is not the full set. CTQ07–CTQ14 cover pin retention, latch set, pane retention, the welfare label, one-mouse capacity, parcel handling, tool drift, and a wash-loosened latch. DFMEA is DF01–DF18 and the control plan is CP01–CP16. Tests T01–T14 are unrun. Deleting one line to simplify steel is a requirement change. The RPNs are proposed and untested. Residual RPN on the ranking sheet is 1579, the 80% review line is 1263.2, and accepted residual is 0.

Result (Y/N/NA): Y

Status: Recorded — requirements listed, untested

BMT-BASIC-SPEC-SHEET-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1 DF01–DF18; BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1 CTQ01–CTQ14; BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1 CP01–CP16;

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Map each CTQ01–CTQ14 line onto the unreleased shell sketch before the feasibility gate. Alex Meadow has not frozen geometry. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. CTQ list is the C1 intent to check. Geometry is not frozen.

Item ID: DFM-02

Question: Does the process fit material, geometry and volume?

Answer / assumption: Production intent is one PP cavity for the BASIC-01 shell and clear window. BASIC-02 door and latch, BASIC-03 trigger and hinge, BASIC-04 bait pocket, and BASIC-06 carton are buy items. The BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 uses 3,000 units a year for 3 years. Printed or machined shells are allowed only as unloaded BASIC-X1 bridge parts. Machining every retail shell was set aside because the window, vents, and internal radii repeat on every unit. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 is 19 rows: BASIC-C1-ASSY and BASIC-01 through BASIC-16, including labor BASIC-05, test aid BASIC-15, and tooling BASIC-16. The buy list above is not the whole bill.

Explanation: Three thousand a year is a manufacturing sensitivity, not demand evidence. Eighteen dated bids are on file for BASIC-01 through BASIC-06: Fictional Sample Works (Perry Voss, 2026-09-12, valid through 2026-12-11), Fictional Meadow Prototype Shop (Willa Marsh, 2026-09-16, valid through 2026-11-15), and Fictional Northline Molding (Eden Crowe, 2026-09-28, valid through 2026-12-27). None is awarded and none is a purchase order. Press tonnage, cycle time, and lead time are not on those bids. The $12,000.00 BASIC-01 / BASIC-16 allowance is not one of the bids.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — bids on file, process limits blank

BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1, 19 rows, BASIC-C1-ASSY and BASIC-01 through BASIC-16; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-QUOTE-COMPARISON-001 Rev C1, 18 unawarded bids dated 2026-09-12, 2026-09-16, and

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: State the 3,000-a-year case, the 50% volume case, and the bridge-only limit against the 18 unawarded bids. Leave BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 unissued. Do not award a tool. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Volume case is a sensitivity. No process is accepted.

Item ID: DFM-03

Question: Are features realistic for the chosen process?

Answer / assumption: No wall, draft, rib, or shutoff is approved. Open points on BASIC-01 are window-frame draft, nominal wall at the clear panel, vent steel that must stay proud of the floor for CTQ02, and latch undercuts on BASIC-02. A bridge print will not show sink, knit lines, or ejection scars.

Explanation: A handbook wall or draft number is not this tool's limit. The limit stays blank until a molder writes it down.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — supplier limits blank

BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1; DF01 and DF02 actions still proposed; BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 capability questions unanswered; no moldflow. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Leave wall, draft, rib, gate, and ejector blank on the BASIC-01 checklist until a supplier fills them. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Feature list is open. No supplier limit is adopted.

Item ID: DFM-04

Question: Are tolerances functional and inspectable?

Answer / assumption: Fits that matter, and are not yet on a drawing, are the latch stack for CTQ01, the slider gap behind the 30 mm finger line for CTQ03, and window readability for CTQ06. The stack has to include PP shrink, wash aging, and latch wear. Window flatness is optical. It is not the latch datum. No gauge repeatability study and no capability study exist.

Explanation: Tolerances that do not serve DF01, DF03, or DF06 will be marked reference so they are not purchased. Nothing has been inspected.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — no dimensioned drawing

BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1 CTQ01, CTQ03, CTQ06; BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1; no dimensioned drawing. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Assign datums and balloon only those CTQ dimensions on the unreleased C1 sketch. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. No datum is released. Tight tolerances are not purchased.

Item ID: DFM-05

Question: Can the parts be assembled consistently?

Answer / assumption: Assembly intent is a keyed hinge pin, an over-center latch, a captive bait pocket, and a door cassette that comes off without tools. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1 has 19 rows: assembly BASIC-C1-ASSY plus BASIC-01 through BASIC-16, including labor BASIC-05, test aid BASIC-15, tooling BASIC-16, and the roll-up. It is not a six-line bill. There is no loose screw. The slider goes in one way only. Planned controls are process steps P01–P14 on BMT-BASIC-PROCESS-FLOW-001, with latch assembly at P05, and PFMEA rows PF01–PF48. None have been run. BASIC-05 inspection labor is $0.55 and has not been timed.

Explanation: A reversed pin is the DF01 escape path. A loose bait insert is the DF05 small-part path. Both are still intent, not a witnessed build.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — no build trial

BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1, 19 rows, BASIC-C1-ASSY and BASIC-01 through BASIC-16; BMT-BASIC-PROCESS-FLOW-001 Rev C1 P01–P14, latch at P05; BMT-BASIC-PFMEA-001 Rev C1 PF01–PF48;

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Tabletop the concept stack, record wrong-way attempts, and file the time against BASIC-05. No live animal. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Assembly intent is not a witnessed build.

Item ID: DFM-06

Question: Can material or supplier substitutions change performance?

Answer / assumption: Do not change the PP shell and window grade, the stainless pivot on BASIC-02, or the acetal on BASIC-03, and do not replace the captive pocket with a loose insert, unless the affected CTQ is regressed. Clear window stock and opaque shell stock are different callouts. Basic has no cell, antenna, propeller, or latch sensor.

Explanation: Designer material lines stay separate from purchasing sources, as on BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001. No approved-alternate list exists. Fictional Sample Works has not offered a substitute.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — no approved alternate

BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1 materials; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 make or buy; DF05 integrate-pocket action; no approved alternate. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Add an allowed-material line on BASIC-01 through BASIC-04 and mark every other grade not allowed. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Substitution ban is recorded. No alternate is approved.

Item ID: DFM-07

Question: Are the files complete and at one revision?

Answer / assumption: BMT-BASIC-BOM-001, BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001, BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001, BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001, R01–R06, and this sheet are all marked C1. There is no released STEP solid, no dimensioned drawing, and no ballooned CTQ print. Economics cases are 3,000 a year, 50% of that rate, and 200% of that rate, as sensitivity only. A render is not the release package.

Explanation: Design freeze is not claimed. The pack carries one revision label, and the manufacturing files are still missing.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Blocked — no released CAD

BMT-BASIC-SPEC-SHEET-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1; no CAD revision. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: List the missing C1 files (STEP, drawing, ballooned CTQs, assembly note, acceptance plan) and keep the pack unreleased. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Revision label is C1. Manufacturing files are missing.

Item ID: DFM-08

Question: What did the manufacturer flag, and who accepted changes?

Answer / assumption: No molder has flagged a feature, and no change has been accepted. Fictional Sample Works is not selected. Eighteen dated bids are on file and unawarded; they are not a DFM markup and not a purchase order. BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 is not issued, and its capability questions are still unanswered. A later markup needs a date, the CTQ it touches, the dollar or tool impact, and acceptance by Alex Meadow. That record does not exist.

Explanation: The BASIC-01 / BASIC-16 shell-and-window figure of $12,000.

Result (Y/N/NA): NA

Status: No DFM markup on file

BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-QUOTE-COMPARISON-001 Rev C1, 18 unawarded bids, no purchase order; BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 Rev C1 not issued, capability questions unanswered;

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Leave BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 unissued until DFM-03 and DFM-09 are filled in. Do not open a disposition log before a DFM markup exists. Do not award a tool. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. No supplier markup exists. Nothing is accepted.

Item ID: DFM-09

Question: Does the tooling spend fit the funded allowance and the volume used to amortize it?

Answer / assumption: BASIC-01 allowance is $12,000.00 for one cavity, amortized at $1.33 per unit across 3,000 units a year for 3 years, inside a packed cost of $5.78. At 50% of stated volume, that amortization doubles to $2.67.00, tests and welfare $4,000.00, market research $2,000.00, design $2,000.00, and unallocated reserve $2,000.00. Nothing is drawn. Each release needs a written consent from Alex Meadow. The $12,000.00 BASIC-01 / BASIC-16 shell-and-window allowance sits outside that cap and is not one of the 18 dated bids. The sheet stops before production tooling. A multi-cavity tool is not in the $12,000.00.

Explanation: Wholesale contribution of $5.22 at the base case does not authorize steel. Alex Meadow is the only person who could approve a tool draw, and has not.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — tool not funded

BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1 BASIC-01 tooling $12,000.00, amortization $1.33, annual units 3,000, years 3; BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 row ECONOMICS-03 packed

Owner: Alex Meadow

Next action: Sam Reed attaches the 50% volume amortization so Alex Meadow can refuse a tool purchase at the feasibility gate. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Tool allowance fails the stop-before-tooling rule.

Item ID: DFM-10

Question: Will gate, knit line, sink, or ejector marks hit a functional or inspection surface?

Answer / assumption: The clear window is the CTQ06 viewing surface and must not carry the gate, a heavy knit line, or an ejector pin. The latch land is the CTQ01 datum and must not sit on a knit line. Vent ribs for CTQ02 will sink if they are thick relative to the wall. No gate side has been chosen. No moldflow file exists.

Explanation: An offer to gate into the window to help flow would be refused under CTQ06. That refusal is written here before any bidder suggests it.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — no moldflow

CTQ01, CTQ02, CTQ06; BASIC-01 PP with clear window; no moldflow file. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Mark gate, ejector, and knit-line keep-out on the unreleased window and latch sketch. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Keep-out is intent only. No moldflow is on file.

Item ID: DFM-11

Question: Are wall, draft, rib, and boss sizes inside a named supplier limit?

Answer / assumption: Not known. No nominal wall, draft angle, rib-to-wall ratio, or boss size is released for BASIC-01. The 18 dated bids do not state a wall, draft, rib, or boss limit.

Explanation: The feasibility gate may close with these four fields blank. It may not close by typing in a generic wall thickness.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — no supplier limit

BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 capability questions unanswered; A handbook wall figure is not used as a measurement. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Add a four-line blank (wall, draft, rib, boss) to the unissued BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 for the supplier to complete. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Wall, draft, rib, and boss stay blank.

Item ID: DFM-12

Question: Which undercuts, side actions, inserts, or steel-safe changes are still open?

Answer / assumption: Features that may force a slide or a shutoff are the BASIC-02 latch undercut, the raised vent slots for DF02, and the window-panel shutoff. Preferred steel-safe direction is to leave metal on the latch land so a weak retention is corrected by cutting steel, not by welding. No slide price sits inside the $12,000.00 allowance.

Explanation: Deleting the latch undercut to avoid a slide reopens DF01 at a proposed RPN of 210. That trade is not accepted.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — slides not priced

DF01 and DF02 proposed actions; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 has no side-action line. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: List each undercut as keep, slide, or redesign, and name the CTQ it protects. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Slides are unnamed. Steel-safe direction is not priced.

Item ID: DFM-13

Question: Can orientation errors and loose hardware be prevented in assembly?

Answer / assumption: Intent is no loose screw, a keyed hinge pin, a one-way slider, and a bait pocket that cannot pass the entrance. Standard hardware is only the stainless pivot already called on BASIC-02. Several PFMEA causes are still written as assembly or configuration error. No wrong-way trial has been recorded.

Explanation: If the pin can be reversed, the proposed occurrence on DF01 does not come down. The poka-yoke has to be on the part, not only on a later inspection.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — no wrong-way trial

BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1 quantities and materials; BMT-BASIC-PFMEA-001 Rev C1 cause lines; no assembly trial. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Sketch the keyed pin and one-way slider and add them as characteristics on PF01. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Poka-yoke is not tried. Occurrence is unchanged.

Item ID: DFM-14

Question: Can the product be washed, serviced, and reassembled without damaging a sealed or energized part?

Answer / assumption: Basic has no battery and no circuit board. The wash plan is tool-free removal of the door cassette, rounded internal corners, and a later fluorescent-soil check on 10 units for CTQ04. Biological cleaning is not claimed. Reassembly has to restore the latch and both vent paths. No wash has been run.

Explanation: A glued window would fail DF04, proposed RPN 240. The window joint has to survive being opened again, or the shell is not the service unit.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — wash not run

DF04; CTQ04; CP04 planned; no wash record. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Confirm on the unreleased model that the cassette comes off without a tool and that both vent banks can be reached. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Service path is intent. No wash record exists.

Item ID: DFM-15

Question: Can every CTQ be measured where the process creates it?

Answer / assumption: CP01 is a cycle rig and a 5 N pull after the latch is assembled. CP02 occludes one vent bank with a paper surrogate. CP03 records the 30 mm finger line on an unloaded task. CP04 is the soil check after washing. CP05 is a pull on the bait pocket. CP06 is a visibility check through the molded window. The control plan is CP01–CP16, not a six-row sheet. CTQ01–CTQ14 and tests T01–T14 are unrun. The latch control is CP01 and its shop step is P05. BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 calls for 10 prototype units, IDs BASIC-X1-001 through BASIC-X1-010. No gauge is on hand and no result is filed.

Explanation: A check of a closed carton does not replace the in-process check. BASIC-05 names labor and a gauge, and the gauge is not identified.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — gauge not named

BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1 CP01–CP16; BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1 CTQ01–CTQ14; BMT-BASIC-TEST-PLAN-001 Rev C1 T01–T14, unrun; planned IDs BASIC-X1-001 through

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Name the gauge or method on each CP01–CP16 row before any bridge unit is called a result. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Control-plan methods are unnamed. No result is filed.

Item ID: DFM-16

Question: Do packaging, labels, and secondary operations change the geometry or the cost?

Answer / assumption: BASIC-06 is a recycled-card carton and instructions at $0.55, already inside the $5.78 packed cost. No drop test, barcode, or date code is specified. The lot mark has to survive washing and must not sit on the window. No pad print, ultrasonic weld, or other secondary operation is in the cost. Shipping-damage testing remains planned under BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 row ECONOMICS-04.

Explanation: A clamshell or a weld added after the quote would change both the geometry and the packed cost. Neither is authorized.

Result (Y/N/NA): N

Status: Open — no packaging trial

BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1 BASIC-06; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 unit cost $0.55; BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 row ECONOMICS-04; no packaging trial. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Reserve a non-window face for a wash-durable lot mark and keep secondary operations at zero until a trial says otherwise. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Pack cost is inside the piece. No pack trial exists.

Item ID: DFM-17

Question: Which high-RPN design features must stay if a supplier offers to simplify the tool or the bill of materials?

Answer / assumption: Do not let a bidder delete the over-center latch and keyed pin (DF01, RPN 210), opposing raised vents (DF02, RPN 252), external slider and hold-open detent (DF03, RPN 192), rounded corners and removable cassette (DF04, RPN 240), integrated bait pocket (DF05, RPN 162), or the clear window (DF06, RPN 432). The highest proposed RPN in this set is 432 on DF06. Every recommended action is still not implemented or tested.

Explanation: A cheaper tool that puts the vents on the floor or glues the cassette shut is a welfare and injury change. It is not a manufacturability cleanup.

Result (Y/N/NA): Y

Status: Recorded — freeze list not signed

BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1 freeze-list rows DF01–DF06, inside the DF01–DF18 index, with proposed RPNs 210, 252, 192, 240, 162, and 432; actions open. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Attach this freeze list to the unissued BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 as characteristics the bidder may not remove. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Freeze list is the refusal rule. Actions stay open.

Item ID: DFM-18

Question: What will the bridge build prove, and what must not be inferred from it?

Answer / assumption: Units BASIC-X1-001 through BASIC-X1-010 may be printed or machined to check fit, unloaded slider reach, and whether the opening can be seen. They will not represent PP shrink, knit lines, vent steel, latch wear after washing, or a production cycle time. A bridge pass is not a first article and is not a reason to cut the $12,000.00 tool. No bridge unit has been built.

Explanation: BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 already says ten prototype units support no reliability inference. This row applies that limit to the process choice.

Result (Y/N/NA): Y

Status: Recorded — bridge limit not signed

BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1 sample note, 10 prototype units, no reliability inference; planned IDs BASIC-X1-001 through BASIC-X1-010; no build record. 2026-10-24.

Owner: Sam Reed

Next action: Add a bridge-versus-production column on BMT-BASIC-TEST-PLAN-001 before any X1 unit is made. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date: Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Bridge limit is recorded. It is not a first article.

Basic — Design for Manufacture and Assembly — supporting detail

Basic — What performance and safety requirements drive the design?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-01

Question. What performance and safety requirements drive the design?

Evidence to record. Intended use, loads, life, environment, interfaces, applicable market rules and acceptance criteria with sources.

Answer / assumption. R01–R06 and CTQ01–CTQ14 set the geometry a tool must not drop: latch hold after 100 dry cycles and a 5 N outward pull (DF01, RPN 210, CP01), raised opposing vents (DF02, RPN 252, CP02), release slider kept 30 mm off the door path (DF03, RPN 192, CP03), tool-free wash of rounded corners (DF04, RPN 240, CP04), captive bait pocket with no loose insert (DF05, RPN 162, CP05), and a clear occupancy window (DF06, RPN 432, CP06). Basic has no radio, battery, or propeller.

Result (Y/N/NA). Y

Explanation. CTQ01–CTQ14 are the features the mold and the assembly have to be able to make. CTQ01–CTQ06 is not the full set. CTQ07–CTQ14 cover pin retention, latch set, pane retention, the welfare label, one-mouse capacity, parcel handling, tool drift, and a wash-loosened latch. DFMEA is DF01–DF18 and the control plan is CP01–CP16. Tests T01–T14 are unrun. Deleting one line to simplify steel is a requirement change. The RPNs are proposed and untested. Residual RPN on the ranking sheet is 1579, the 80% review line is 1263.2, and accepted residual is 0.

Status. Recorded — requirements listed, untested

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-SPEC-SHEET-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1 DF01–DF18; BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1 CTQ01–CTQ14; BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1 CP01–CP16; BMT-BASIC-TEST-PLAN-001 Rev C1 T01–T14, unrun; BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1; no external evidence. Internal read 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Map each CTQ01–CTQ14 line onto the unreleased shell sketch before the feasibility gate. Alex Meadow has not frozen geometry. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. CTQ list is the C1 intent to check. Geometry is not frozen.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-SPEC-SHEET-001 Rev C1

Basic — Does the process fit material, geometry and volume?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-02

Question. Does the process fit material, geometry and volume?

Evidence to record. Compare machining, molding, casting, sheet metal, additive or other processes against quantity, finish, lead time, tooling and total cost; identify process-specific risks.

Answer / assumption. Production intent is one PP cavity for the BASIC-01 shell and clear window. BASIC-02 door and latch, BASIC-03 trigger and hinge, BASIC-04 bait pocket, and BASIC-06 carton are buy items. The BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 uses 3,000 units a year for 3 years. Printed or machined shells are allowed only as unloaded BASIC-X1 bridge parts. Machining every retail shell was set aside because the window, vents, and internal radii repeat on every unit. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 is 19 rows: BASIC-C1-ASSY and BASIC-01 through BASIC-16, including labor BASIC-05, test aid BASIC-15, and tooling BASIC-16. The buy list above is not the whole bill.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. Three thousand a year is a manufacturing sensitivity, not demand evidence. Eighteen dated bids are on file for BASIC-01 through BASIC-06: Fictional Sample Works (Perry Voss, 2026-09-12, valid through 2026-12-11), Fictional Meadow Prototype Shop (Willa Marsh, 2026-09-16, valid through 2026-11-15), and Fictional Northline Molding (Eden Crowe, 2026-09-28, valid through 2026-12-27). None is awarded and none is a purchase order. Press tonnage, cycle time, and lead time are not on those bids. The $12,000.00 BASIC-01 / BASIC-16 allowance is not one of the bids.

Status. Open — bids on file, process limits blank

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1, 19 rows, BASIC-C1-ASSY and BASIC-01 through BASIC-16; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-QUOTE-COMPARISON-001 Rev C1, 18 unawarded bids dated 2026-09-12, 2026-09-16, and 2026-09-28; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 annual units 3,000 and years 3; no tonnage, cycle, or lead time on the bids. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. State the 3,000-a-year case, the 50% volume case, and the bridge-only limit against the 18 unawarded bids. Leave BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 unissued. Do not award a tool. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Volume case is a sensitivity. No process is accepted.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1

Basic — Are features realistic for the chosen process?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-03

Question. Are features realistic for the chosen process?

Evidence to record. For molding: walls, draft, ribs/bosses, undercuts, shrinkage and ejection. For machining: tool access, deep pockets and corner radii. For sheet metal: bends, radii and hole spacing. Obtain the actual supplier’s limits; no universal wall/draft number.

Answer / assumption. No wall, draft, rib, or shutoff is approved. Open points on BASIC-01 are window-frame draft, nominal wall at the clear panel, vent steel that must stay proud of the floor for CTQ02, and latch undercuts on BASIC-02. A bridge print will not show sink, knit lines, or ejection scars.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. A handbook wall or draft number is not this tool's limit. The limit stays blank until a molder writes it down.

Status. Open — supplier limits blank

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1; DF01 and DF02 actions still proposed; BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 capability questions unanswered; no moldflow. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Leave wall, draft, rib, gate, and ejector blank on the BASIC-01 checklist until a supplier fills them. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Feature list is open. No supplier limit is adopted.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 Rev C1

Basic — Are tolerances functional and inspectable?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-04

Question. Are tolerances functional and inspectable?

Evidence to record. Critical dimensions, datums, fits, tolerance stack-ups, finishes and inspection methods. Avoid needless tight tolerances; specify those required for function or safety.

Answer / assumption. Fits that matter, and are not yet on a drawing, are the latch stack for CTQ01, the slider gap behind the 30 mm finger line for CTQ03, and window readability for CTQ06. The stack has to include PP shrink, wash aging, and latch wear. Window flatness is optical. It is not the latch datum. No gauge repeatability study and no capability study exist.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. Tolerances that do not serve DF01, DF03, or DF06 will be marked reference so they are not purchased. Nothing has been inspected.

Status. Open — no dimensioned drawing

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1 CTQ01, CTQ03, CTQ06; BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1; no dimensioned drawing. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Assign datums and balloon only those CTQ dimensions on the unreleased C1 sketch. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. No datum is released. Tight tolerances are not purchased.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1

Basic — Can the parts be assembled consistently?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-05

Question. Can the parts be assembled consistently?

Evidence to record. Reduce unnecessary parts/fasteners, use standard components, access tools, orient and locate parts, prevent wrong assembly, protect wires/seals and test service/disassembly.

Answer / assumption. Assembly intent is a keyed hinge pin, an over-center latch, a captive bait pocket, and a door cassette that comes off without tools. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1 has 19 rows: assembly BASIC-C1-ASSY plus BASIC-01 through BASIC-16, including labor BASIC-05, test aid BASIC-15, tooling BASIC-16, and the roll-up. It is not a six-line bill. There is no loose screw. The slider goes in one way only. Planned controls are process steps P01–P14 on BMT-BASIC-PROCESS-FLOW-001, with latch assembly at P05, and PFMEA rows PF01–PF48. None have been run. BASIC-05 inspection labor is $0.55 and has not been timed.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. A reversed pin is the DF01 escape path. A loose bait insert is the DF05 small-part path. Both are still intent, not a witnessed build.

Status. Open — no build trial

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1, 19 rows, BASIC-C1-ASSY and BASIC-01 through BASIC-16; BMT-BASIC-PROCESS-FLOW-001 Rev C1 P01–P14, latch at P05; BMT-BASIC-PFMEA-001 Rev C1 PF01–PF48; BMT-BASIC-WORK-INSTRUCTIONS-001 Rev C1 draft with no build record. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Tabletop the concept stack, record wrong-way attempts, and file the time against BASIC-05. No live animal. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Assembly intent is not a witnessed build.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-PROCESS-FLOW-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-PFMEA-001 Rev C1

Basic — Can material or supplier substitutions change performance?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-06

Question. Can material or supplier substitutions change performance?

Evidence to record. Material/grade, flame/contact/corrosion requirements, finishes, standard hardware and qualified equivalents. Preserve designer catalog references separately from purchasing sources.

Answer / assumption. Do not change the PP shell and window grade, the stainless pivot on BASIC-02, or the acetal on BASIC-03, and do not replace the captive pocket with a loose insert, unless the affected CTQ is regressed. Clear window stock and opaque shell stock are different callouts. Basic has no cell, antenna, propeller, or latch sensor.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. Designer material lines stay separate from purchasing sources, as on BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001. No approved-alternate list exists. Fictional Sample Works has not offered a substitute.

Status. Open — no approved alternate

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1 materials; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 make or buy; DF05 integrate-pocket action; no approved alternate. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Add an allowed-material line on BASIC-01 through BASIC-04 and mark every other grade not allowed. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Substitution ban is recorded. No alternate is approved.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1

Basic — Are the files complete and at one revision?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-07

Question. Are the files complete and at one revision?

Evidence to record. Bill of materials, STEP solid and dimensioned drawings where applicable, materials/finishes, critical characteristics, assembly notes, quantity breaks and inspection/acceptance requirements. A render is not a release package.

Answer / assumption. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001, BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001, BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001, BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001, R01–R06, and this sheet are all marked C1. There is no released STEP solid, no dimensioned drawing, and no ballooned CTQ print. Economics cases are 3,000 a year, 50% of that rate, and 200% of that rate, as sensitivity only. A render is not the release package.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. Design freeze is not claimed. The pack carries one revision label, and the manufacturing files are still missing.

Status. Blocked — no released CAD

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-SPEC-SHEET-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1; no CAD revision. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. List the missing C1 files (STEP, drawing, ballooned CTQs, assembly note, acceptance plan) and keep the pack unreleased. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Revision label is C1. Manufacturing files are missing.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1

Basic — What did the manufacturer flag, and who accepted changes?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-08

Question. What did the manufacturer flag, and who accepted changes?

Evidence to record. Dated supplier DFM feedback, disposition, affected requirements, cost/tooling impact, owner and verification/retest. Obtain review before releasing revised work.

Answer / assumption. No molder has flagged a feature, and no change has been accepted. Fictional Sample Works is not selected. Eighteen dated bids are on file and unawarded; they are not a DFM markup and not a purchase order. BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 is not issued, and its capability questions are still unanswered. A later markup needs a date, the CTQ it touches, the dollar or tool impact, and acceptance by Alex Meadow. That record does not exist.

Result (Y/N/NA). NA

Status. No DFM markup on file

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Leave BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 unissued until DFM-03 and DFM-09 are filled in. Do not open a disposition log before a DFM markup exists. Do not award a tool. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. No supplier markup exists. Nothing is accepted.

Not-applicable reason. Price bids are on file and unawarded. No DFM markup has been accepted, so there is no markup to disposition.

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-FUNDING-WORKSHEET-001 Rev C1

Basic — Does the tooling spend fit the funded allowance and the volume used to amortize it?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-09

Question. Does the tooling spend fit the funded allowance and the volume used to amortize it?

Evidence to record. Tool identity, cavity count, ownership, allowance versus any quote, funded cash and the stop-before-tooling rule, annual units and years used for amortization, packed unit cost at the stated volume and at half volume, and who may authorize a purchase.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. Wholesale contribution of $5.22 at the base case does not authorize steel. Alex Meadow is the only person who could approve a tool draw, and has not.

Status. Open — tool not funded

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1 BASIC-01 tooling $12,000.00, amortization $1.33, annual units 3,000, years 3; BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 row ECONOMICS-03 packed $5.78; BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 row ECONOMICS-06 wholesale $5. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Alex Meadow

Next action. Sam Reed attaches the 50% volume amortization so Alex Meadow can refuse a tool purchase at the feasibility gate. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Tool allowance fails the stop-before-tooling rule.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-FUNDING-WORKSHEET-001 Rev C1

Basic — Will gate, knit line, sink, or ejector marks hit a functional or inspection surface?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-10

Question. Will gate, knit line, sink, or ejector marks hit a functional or inspection surface?

Evidence to record. Proposed gate, bond, or witness location; knit or weld line versus latch, window, and other datums; sink at ribs and bosses; surfaces that are cosmetic, optical, or functional. A moldflow or construction review is evidence. A render is not.

Answer / assumption. The clear window is the CTQ06 viewing surface and must not carry the gate, a heavy knit line, or an ejector pin. The latch land is the CTQ01 datum and must not sit on a knit line. Vent ribs for CTQ02 will sink if they are thick relative to the wall. No gate side has been chosen. No moldflow file exists.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. An offer to gate into the window to help flow would be refused under CTQ06. That refusal is written here before any bidder suggests it.

Status. Open — no moldflow

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. CTQ01, CTQ02, CTQ06; BASIC-01 PP with clear window; no moldflow file. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Mark gate, ejector, and knit-line keep-out on the unreleased window and latch sketch. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Keep-out is intent only. No moldflow is on file.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1

Basic — Are wall, draft, rib, and boss sizes inside a named supplier limit?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-11

Question. Are wall, draft, rib, and boss sizes inside a named supplier limit?

Evidence to record. Nominal wall, thin-to-thick ratio, draft by surface, rib and boss size versus wall, corner radii, and the named supplier's written limit. Do not copy a universal wall or draft number. Record machining or composite limits the same way when the part is not molded.

Answer / assumption. Not known. No nominal wall, draft angle, rib-to-wall ratio, or boss size is released for BASIC-01. The 18 dated bids do not state a wall, draft, rib, or boss limit.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. The feasibility gate may close with these four fields blank. It may not close by typing in a generic wall thickness.

Status. Open — no supplier limit

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 capability questions unanswered; A handbook wall figure is not used as a measurement. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Add a four-line blank (wall, draft, rib, boss) to the unissued BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 for the supplier to complete. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Wall, draft, rib, and boss stay blank.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CONCEPT-DRAWING-001 Rev C1

Basic — Which undercuts, side actions, inserts, or steel-safe changes are still open?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-12

Question. Which undercuts, side actions, inserts, or steel-safe changes are still open?

Evidence to record. Each undercut, side action, insert, or shutoff; the requirement it serves; steel-safe or bond-safe direction; added tool or fixture cost; and the failure mode reopened if the feature is deleted to simplify the process.

Answer / assumption. Features that may force a slide or a shutoff are the BASIC-02 latch undercut, the raised vent slots for DF02, and the window-panel shutoff. Preferred steel-safe direction is to leave metal on the latch land so a weak retention is corrected by cutting steel, not by welding. No slide price sits inside the $12,000.00 allowance.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. Deleting the latch undercut to avoid a slide reopens DF01 at a proposed RPN of 210. That trade is not accepted.

Status. Open — slides not priced

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. DF01 and DF02 proposed actions; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 has no side-action line. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. List each undercut as keep, slide, or redesign, and name the CTQ it protects. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Slides are unnamed. Steel-safe direction is not priced.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 Rev C1

Basic — Can orientation errors and loose hardware be prevented in assembly?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-13

Question. Can orientation errors and loose hardware be prevented in assembly?

Evidence to record. Part count, standard versus special hardware, keyed or captive features, wrong-way trials, tool access, wires and seals, and a timed build at the planned station. Link each credible error to the PFMEA row.

Answer / assumption. Intent is no loose screw, a keyed hinge pin, a one-way slider, and a bait pocket that cannot pass the entrance. Standard hardware is only the stainless pivot already called on BASIC-02. Several PFMEA causes are still written as assembly or configuration error. No wrong-way trial has been recorded.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. If the pin can be reversed, the proposed occurrence on DF01 does not come down. The poka-yoke has to be on the part, not only on a later inspection.

Status. Open — no wrong-way trial

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1 quantities and materials; BMT-BASIC-PFMEA-001 Rev C1 cause lines; no assembly trial. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Sketch the keyed pin and one-way slider and add them as characteristics on PF01. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Poka-yoke is not tried. Occurrence is unchanged.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-PFMEA-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1

Basic — Can the product be washed, serviced, and reassembled without damaging a sealed or energized part?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-14

Question. Can the product be washed, serviced, and reassembled without damaging a sealed or energized part?

Evidence to record. Tool-free steps, wet zone versus sealed or energized parts, battery and electronics removal, fastener reuse, and the wash or service sequence. Do not claim an ingress rating without a test record.

Answer / assumption. Basic has no battery and no circuit board. The wash plan is tool-free removal of the door cassette, rounded internal corners, and a later fluorescent-soil check on 10 units for CTQ04. Biological cleaning is not claimed. Reassembly has to restore the latch and both vent paths. No wash has been run.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. A glued window would fail DF04, proposed RPN 240. The window joint has to survive being opened again, or the shell is not the service unit.

Status. Open — wash not run

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. DF04; CTQ04; CP04 planned; no wash record. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Confirm on the unreleased model that the cassette comes off without a tool and that both vent banks can be reached. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Service path is intent. No wash record exists.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1

Basic — Can every CTQ be measured where the process creates it?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-15

Question. Can every CTQ be measured where the process creates it?

Evidence to record. Each CTQ, its datum, gauge or method, sample size, whether the characteristic is still reachable after the next operation, and the control-plan row. A control-plan line with no gauge is not a result.

Answer / assumption. CP01 is a cycle rig and a 5 N pull after the latch is assembled. CP02 occludes one vent bank with a paper surrogate. CP03 records the 30 mm finger line on an unloaded task. CP04 is the soil check after washing. CP05 is a pull on the bait pocket. CP06 is a visibility check through the molded window. The control plan is CP01–CP16, not a six-row sheet. CTQ01–CTQ14 and tests T01–T14 are unrun. The latch control is CP01 and its shop step is P05. BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 calls for 10 prototype units, IDs BASIC-X1-001 through BASIC-X1-010. No gauge is on hand and no result is filed.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. A check of a closed carton does not replace the in-process check. BASIC-05 names labor and a gauge, and the gauge is not identified.

Status. Open — gauge not named

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1 CP01–CP16; BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1 CTQ01–CTQ14; BMT-BASIC-TEST-PLAN-001 Rev C1 T01–T14, unrun; planned IDs BASIC-X1-001 through BASIC-X1-010; shop step for the latch control is P05; no measurement record. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Name the gauge or method on each CP01–CP16 row before any bridge unit is called a result. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Control-plan methods are unnamed. No result is filed.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CRITICAL-QUALITY-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-TEST-MATRIX-001 Rev C1

Basic — Do packaging, labels, and secondary operations change the geometry or the cost?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-16

Question. Do packaging, labels, and secondary operations change the geometry or the cost?

Evidence to record. Carton or crate, label and lot-mark location, surfaces the mark must not cover, secondary operations and their cost, and whether that cost is already inside the packed unit cost. Note any drop or damage trial as planned or done.

Answer / assumption. BASIC-06 is a recycled-card carton and instructions at $0.55, already inside the $5.78 packed cost. No drop test, barcode, or date code is specified. The lot mark has to survive washing and must not sit on the window. No pad print, ultrasonic weld, or other secondary operation is in the cost. Shipping-damage testing remains planned under BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 row ECONOMICS-04.

Result (Y/N/NA). N

Explanation. A clamshell or a weld added after the quote would change both the geometry and the packed cost. Neither is authorized.

Status. Open — no packaging trial

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1 BASIC-06; BMT-BASIC-TEMPLATE-COST-SHEET-001 unit cost $0.55; BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 row ECONOMICS-04; no packaging trial. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Reserve a non-window face for a wash-durable lot mark and keep secondary operations at zero until a trial says otherwise. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Pack cost is inside the piece. No pack trial exists.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-BOM-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-CHECK-SHEET-ECONOMICS-001 Rev C1

Basic — Which high-RPN design features must stay if a supplier offers to simplify the tool or the bill of materials?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-17

Question. Which high-RPN design features must stay if a supplier offers to simplify the tool or the bill of materials?

Evidence to record. DFMEA ID, proposed RPN, feature, the simplification a supplier might offer, the requirement that simplification would break, and the person who must refuse it. State that the ratings are proposed and untested.

Answer / assumption. Do not let a bidder delete the over-center latch and keyed pin (DF01, RPN 210), opposing raised vents (DF02, RPN 252), external slider and hold-open detent (DF03, RPN 192), rounded corners and removable cassette (DF04, RPN 240), integrated bait pocket (DF05, RPN 162), or the clear window (DF06, RPN 432). The highest proposed RPN in this set is 432 on DF06. Every recommended action is still not implemented or tested.

Result (Y/N/NA). Y

Explanation. A cheaper tool that puts the vents on the floor or glues the cassette shut is a welfare and injury change. It is not a manufacturability cleanup.

Status. Recorded — freeze list not signed

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1 freeze-list rows DF01–DF06, inside the DF01–DF18 index, with proposed RPNs 210, 252, 192, 240, 162, and 432; actions open. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Attach this freeze list to the unissued BMT-BASIC-RFQ-PACKAGE-001 as characteristics the bidder may not remove. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Freeze list is the refusal rule. Actions stay open.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-DFMEA-001 Rev C1

Basic — What will the bridge build prove, and what must not be inferred from it?

Project. Basic

Product revision. C1

Sheet revision. 1

Prepared by. Sam Reed

Date. 2026-10-24

Target market / jurisdiction. U.S. adults; Wisconsin illustrative base

Decision being prepared. Next private feasibility gate

Sheet. Design for Manufacture and Assembly

Lead. Sam Reed

Item ID. DFM-18

Question. What will the bridge build prove, and what must not be inferred from it?

Evidence to record. Bridge process, unit-ID series, which CTQs the bridge article can exercise, which production features it cannot represent, and the rule that a bridge pass is not first-article acceptance and not tool authorization.

Answer / assumption. Units BASIC-X1-001 through BASIC-X1-010 may be printed or machined to check fit, unloaded slider reach, and whether the opening can be seen. They will not represent PP shrink, knit lines, vent steel, latch wear after washing, or a production cycle time. A bridge pass is not a first article and is not a reason to cut the $12,000.00 tool. No bridge unit has been built.

Result (Y/N/NA). Y

Explanation. BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 already says ten prototype units support no reliability inference. This row applies that limit to the process choice.

Status. Recorded — bridge limit not signed

Evidence / exact revision / URL and date. BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1 sample note, 10 prototype units, no reliability inference; planned IDs BASIC-X1-001 through BASIC-X1-010; no build record. 2026-10-24.

Owner. Sam Reed

Next action. Add a bridge-versus-production column on BMT-BASIC-TEST-PLAN-001 before any X1 unit is made. Target 2026-12-15.

Reviewer / review date. Pending. Casey Holt, planned 2026-11-01. Bridge limit is recorded. It is not a first article.

Not-applicable reason. Applicable

Source guidance URLs. BMT-BASIC-CONTROL-PLAN-001 Rev C1; BMT-BASIC-TEST-PLAN-001 Rev C1

Document administration

Preparation: Sam Reed, scenario attribution, 2026-10-24. Signature: unsigned. Review: pending; no reviewer signature or date. Approval: withheld; no approver signature or date.

Prepared byDate
Reviewed byDate
Approved byDate