THE BETTER MOUSE TRAP CO. · COMPLETED METHOD RECORD

5 Whys and fishbone — verified causes

DocumentBMT-FIVE-WHYS-AND-FISHBONE-D1
Revision / review dateD1 · 2027-06-30
Accountable ownerAlex Meadow
Six Ms: two hypotheses per branch; cause labels stay inside boxes and connectors stop at their edges. Confirmed hinge clearance and debounce causes feed the 5 Whys.Rebound /missed alertManpowerOperator crossover rejectedTraining omission rejectedMachineHinge play confirmedDoor mass screenedMethodDebounce reset confirmedCTQ sign-off absentMaterialResin swap rejectedPin lot variation rejectedMeasurementGauge bias rejectedVisual seating unreliableMother NatureBedding surrogate rejectedIndoor temperature screened
Six Ms organize the tested hypotheses. Hinge clearance and debounce were confirmed; rejected hypotheses remain visible for comparison.

Scope: 5 Whys and fishbone — verified causes. Read the observations and decisions below within their stated conditions.

Basic · occurrence and escape chains

WhyOccurrence chain / supporting evidenceEscape chain / supporting evidence
1Door rebounds: latch does not hold; video BL-B shows 12/100Bad units reached rig because seating was judged visually
2Latch misses because hinge moves laterally; measured 0.45 mm playVisual check cannot resolve hinge play; 2 assessors disagreed on 4/20 units
3Clearance stack allowed play; drawing C1 max gap 1.40 mmNo functional retention check in C1 inspection
4Tolerance review excluded the hinge stack; review checklist confirms omissionControl plan copied appearance check without CTQ trace
5Design-release checklist lacked tolerance-stack and control-plan trace fieldsRelease review lacked independent CTQ-to-test sign-off; meeting C1 confirms omission

Mouse Hotel · causal chain and verification

Why / testFindingDisposition
1–28/100 alerts missed because occupancy flag clears during short dropoutEvent trace replay reproduced 8/100
3–5Debounce used momentary sensing, requirement omitted retained occupancy, review had no dropout testJordan corrected requirement and state machine ECN-D1-02
Cause verificationSame 100 recorded traces replayed: old code 8 misses, D1 0 misses; 1000 independent events 0 missesIra Bell 2027-06-18
Why / testFindingDisposition
Basic verificationShim-only crossover removed 12/100 failures; D1 keyed hinge 0/1000; visual-only check retiredSam Reed; Alex approved 2027-06-25
Fishbone conclusionSix branches are hypotheses; only hinge clearance and debounce path were confirmed. Training, resin, bedding and gauge bias were tested and rejectedSigned Sam Reed / Jordan Vale / Ira Bell, 2027-06-30

Record reviewed and signed: Alex Meadow, 2027-06-30. Technical review: Sam Reed / Jordan Vale; independent check: Ira Bell. Disposition: use for the stated internal scope only.

Compare the reference example. Teaching data and signed dispositions: D1 scenario register.