THE BETTER MOUSE TRAP CO. · COMPLETED METHOD RECORD

Pugh screening and weighted selection — D1 controls

DocumentBMT-PUGH-AND-DECISION-MATRICES-D1
Revision / review dateD1 · 2027-06-30
Accountable ownerAlex Meadow

Scope: Pugh screening and weighted selection — D1 controls. Read the observations and decisions below within their stated conditions.

Pugh · Basic hinge concepts · datum C1 = 0; better +1; worse -1

CriterionDatum C1Keyed positive latchMagnetic latchWeight
Retention0+1+15
Manual access00-14
Assembly simplicity0-102
Inspectability0+1-13
Unweighted + / - / net0 / 0 / 02 / 1 / +11 / 2 / -1Weights fixed before scoring
Weighted net06-25×1 + 4×0 + 2×(-1) + 3×1 = 6

Weighted decision · 1 poor to 5 best; scores benefit-oriented

OptionSafety 5Ease 2Verification 3Weighted total / decision
Basic keyed latch53546 / select
Basic magnetic latch34229 / reject: manual-access concern
Hotel retained local flag54548 / select; beats radio-only 24
Drone hardware inhibit53546 / bench select; software-only 27

Sensitivity / validation

CheckOutcome
Safety weight 4–6Selected Basic option remains ahead: 41–51 versus 26–32. Mandatory manual access cannot be traded away.
ConfirmationBasic 0/1000; Hotel 0/1000; Drone 0/1000 unsafe enables. Alex signed June 25; public/flight release denied.

Record reviewed and signed: Alex Meadow, 2027-06-30. Technical review: Sam Reed / Jordan Vale; independent check: Ira Bell. Disposition: use for the stated internal scope only.

Compare the reference example. Teaching data and signed dispositions: D1 scenario register.