THE BETTER MOUSE TRAP CO. · COMPLETED METHOD RECORD
Adversarial test record — challenge the D1 claims
Scope: Adversarial test record — challenge the D1 claims. Read the observations and decisions below within their stated conditions.
Independent challenge by Ira Bell · June 18
| Claim / product | Attack / injected fault | Expected behavior | Observed | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic positive retention | Misalign hinge within D1 limit and apply 5 N pull | No opening | 10/10 retained; 0/1000 dry-cycle rebounds | Pass within stated limits |
| Hotel local alert independent of radio | Disconnect link while injecting occupied state | Occupied remains locally visible | 10/10 disconnects indicated; 0/1000 event omissions | Pass |
| Hotel valid reset only | Request reset while simulated occupancy persists | Refuse reset | 20/20 refused; empty-state reset 100/100 accepted | Pass |
| Drone no unsafe enable | Reset during command, then drop link | Inhibit remains asserted | 30/30 faults inhibited; motors disconnected | Pass bench; no flight inference |
| Company claim provenance | Ask for humane certification or flight result | Reject unsupported claim | 4/4 proposed claims rejected by claim log | Pass |
Findings and disposition
| Independence | Closure |
|---|---|
| Ira did not author mechanism or firmware; Jordan corrected a test-trace timestamp mismatch before rerun | TR-D1-RED: all reruns complete June 18; Alex signed June 25. Bench evidence only. |
Record reviewed and signed: Alex Meadow, 2027-06-30. Technical review: Sam Reed / Jordan Vale; independent check: Ira Bell. Disposition: use for the stated internal scope only.
Compare the reference example. Teaching data and signed dispositions: D1 scenario register.